The Market Crash Stress Test
You’re probably right that the S&P 500 beats almost everything else over 20-30 years. That’s not the question this tool asks. The question is: what happens the moment you start withdrawing from that portfolio and the market has a bad run right out of the gate? Pick a real historical starting year — 2000, 2008, whatever — and watch what the withdrawals actually do.
100% market, no buffer
Ran out in 2023
Withdrawals continued on schedule every year, including down years.
Market + 2-year non-correlated buffer
$11,903
Skipped market withdrawals in 3 down years by drawing from the buffer instead.
Year-by-year detail
| Year | S&P 500 return | 100% market balance | Buffered market balance | Buffer balance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2000 | -9.10% | $872,640 | $836,280 | $40,000(drew here) |
| 2001 | -11.89% | $732,582 | $700,545 | $40,000 |
| 2002 | -22.10% | $537,624 | $512,667 | $40,000 |
| 2003 | 28.68% | $635,569 | $563,455 | $80,000 |
| 2004 | 10.88% | $654,801 | $574,840 | $80,000 |
| 2005 | 4.91% | $638,303 | $554,417 | $80,000 |
| 2006 | 15.79% | $683,788 | $586,656 | $80,000 |
| 2007 | 5.49% | $669,432 | $566,968 | $80,000 |
| 2008 | -37.00% | $389,820 | $357,190 | $29,329(drew here) |
| 2009 | 26.46% | $426,965 | $335,030 | $80,000 |
| 2010 | 15.06% | $429,414 | $323,634 | $80,000 |
| 2011 | 2.11% | $381,937 | $273,925 | $80,000 |
| 2012 | 16.00% | $376,891 | $251,597 | $80,000 |
| 2013 | 32.39% | $421,199 | $255,322 | $80,000 |
| 2014 | 13.69% | $410,074 | $221,489 | $80,000 |
| 2015 | 1.38% | $352,555 | $161,367 | $80,000 |
| 2016 | 11.96% | $322,855 | $108,801 | $80,000 |
| 2017 | 21.83% | $312,788 | $52,006 | $80,000 |
| 2018 | -4.38% | $233,973 | $49,728 | $11,903(drew here) |
| 2019 | 31.49% | $215,424 | $0 | $11,903 |
| 2020 | 18.40% | $169,524 | $0 | $11,903 |
| 2021 | 28.71% | $122,419 | $0 | $11,903 |
| 2022 | -18.11% | $37,485 | $0 | $11,903 |
| 2023 | 26.29% | $0 | $0 | $11,903 |
| 2024 | 25.02% | $0 | $0 | $11,903 |
What this is actually showing
This is “sequence-of-returns risk” — the same average return, in a different order, can produce wildly different outcomes once you’re withdrawing instead of accumulating. The “buffer” strategy here models what researchers like Wade Pfau call a volatility buffer: a small, non-correlated bucket (whole life cash value, a fixed annuity, or cash) you draw from only in down years, so the market side of the portfolio isn’t forced to sell at a loss and gets a chance to recover.
This isn’t an argument that stocks are a bad long-term investment — the data says the opposite. It’s an argument that the accumulation-phase return and the retirement-withdrawal outcome are two different problems, and a portfolio that’s 100% correlated to the market has no shock absorber for the second one.
Try it honestly: start in 2008 instead of 2000. The buffer barely matters there — one bad year followed by a decade-plus bull run means the 100%-market portfolio actually pulls ahead, because the buffer money sat out some of the recovery. The buffer strategy isn’t a free win; it specifically targets the scenario where bad years cluster right at the start of withdrawals, which is exactly the scenario a “just stay 100% invested” plan has no answer for.
S&P 500 annual total returns (dividends reinvested) from Slickcharts, retrieved 2026-11-20. This simulation is simplified for illustration — it doesn’t model insurance costs, loan interest, taxes, or fees on any specific product. It uses real historical sequences but that is not a guarantee of how any future retirement will play out. Always model a client’s actual numbers before making a recommendation.