SSafora

The Market Crash Stress Test

You’re probably right that the S&P 500 beats almost everything else over 20-30 years. That’s not the question this tool asks. The question is: what happens the moment you start withdrawing from that portfolio and the market has a bad run right out of the gate? Pick a real historical starting year — 2000, 2008, whatever — and watch what the withdrawals actually do.

Educational use only. Calculators and illustrative outputs on this site are for learning purposes. They do not constitute insurance, tax, legal, or investment advice. Past performance and estimates do not guarantee future results.

100% market, no buffer

Ran out in 2023

Withdrawals continued on schedule every year, including down years.

Market + 2-year non-correlated buffer

$11,903

Skipped market withdrawals in 3 down years by drawing from the buffer instead.

$0$219,000$438,000$657,000$876,0002000200420082012201620202024
100% market Market + buffer (combined)
Year-by-year detail
YearS&P 500 return100% market balanceBuffered market balanceBuffer balance
2000-9.10%$872,640$836,280$40,000(drew here)
2001-11.89%$732,582$700,545$40,000
2002-22.10%$537,624$512,667$40,000
200328.68%$635,569$563,455$80,000
200410.88%$654,801$574,840$80,000
20054.91%$638,303$554,417$80,000
200615.79%$683,788$586,656$80,000
20075.49%$669,432$566,968$80,000
2008-37.00%$389,820$357,190$29,329(drew here)
200926.46%$426,965$335,030$80,000
201015.06%$429,414$323,634$80,000
20112.11%$381,937$273,925$80,000
201216.00%$376,891$251,597$80,000
201332.39%$421,199$255,322$80,000
201413.69%$410,074$221,489$80,000
20151.38%$352,555$161,367$80,000
201611.96%$322,855$108,801$80,000
201721.83%$312,788$52,006$80,000
2018-4.38%$233,973$49,728$11,903(drew here)
201931.49%$215,424$0$11,903
202018.40%$169,524$0$11,903
202128.71%$122,419$0$11,903
2022-18.11%$37,485$0$11,903
202326.29%$0$0$11,903
202425.02%$0$0$11,903

What this is actually showing

This is “sequence-of-returns risk” — the same average return, in a different order, can produce wildly different outcomes once you’re withdrawing instead of accumulating. The “buffer” strategy here models what researchers like Wade Pfau call a volatility buffer: a small, non-correlated bucket (whole life cash value, a fixed annuity, or cash) you draw from only in down years, so the market side of the portfolio isn’t forced to sell at a loss and gets a chance to recover.

This isn’t an argument that stocks are a bad long-term investment — the data says the opposite. It’s an argument that the accumulation-phase return and the retirement-withdrawal outcome are two different problems, and a portfolio that’s 100% correlated to the market has no shock absorber for the second one.

Try it honestly: start in 2008 instead of 2000. The buffer barely matters there — one bad year followed by a decade-plus bull run means the 100%-market portfolio actually pulls ahead, because the buffer money sat out some of the recovery. The buffer strategy isn’t a free win; it specifically targets the scenario where bad years cluster right at the start of withdrawals, which is exactly the scenario a “just stay 100% invested” plan has no answer for.

S&P 500 annual total returns (dividends reinvested) from Slickcharts, retrieved 2026-11-20. This simulation is simplified for illustration — it doesn’t model insurance costs, loan interest, taxes, or fees on any specific product. It uses real historical sequences but that is not a guarantee of how any future retirement will play out. Always model a client’s actual numbers before making a recommendation.